Juries handed trucking and automotive defendants $3.4 billion in nuclear verdicts in 2025, nearly three times the $1.4 billion of the year before, according to the 2026 edition of Marathon Strategies' report Corporate Verdicts Go Thermonuclear, which Transport Topics covered this week. The money came from fewer cases: 12 in 2025 against 15 in 2024. The report defines a nuclear verdict as a jury award of $10 million or more, and it counted nearly 200 of them across all industries last year, worth $25.6 billion, a 40.7% jump from 2024 and the highest annual total since Marathon began counting in 2023. The reason this matters to a driver who has never been sued is simple: every one of those awards is priced into the next insurance renewal, and the way plaintiffs' lawyers are building these cases now reaches well past the person behind the wheel.
What the numbers say
Marathon, a New York public relations firm that specializes in crisis work, compiles the report from VerdictSearch, LexisNexis jury-verdict data and court records. Its 2025 findings: nearly 200 verdicts of $10 million or more, more than 40 above $100 million for the second straight year, and four above $1 billion. Sixty-eight industries took at least one nuclear verdict, up from 55 in 2024 and 48 in 2023. Beverage companies faced the largest total at $3.8 billion, with pharmaceuticals and automakers at $2.9 billion each. Products liability drove the biggest awards, $12 billion across 29 cases. 'The sum of verdicts against the trucking and automotive industries nearly tripled in 2025, rising to 12 cases for $3.4 billion, compared with 15 cases for $1.4 billion in 2024,' the report says. 'These sectors are among the top targets of nuclear verdicts, mainly in wrongful-death and negligence cases.'
Geography still matters. Georgia led the country with $4.9 billion in nuclear verdicts, driven by two multibillion-dollar liability cases, and Nevada, Texas, California and Florida rounded out the top five. Marathon told Transport Topics that Texas juries produced $3.4 billion, California $2.6 billion, Florida $2.5 billion and Maryland $1.7 billion. Florida is the cautionary tale for anyone counting on tort reform: the state's 2023 law, House Bill 837, was supposed to cool things down, yet Florida returned to the top five in 2025 with 20 nuclear verdicts. Marathon's founder Phil Singer explained why to Transport Topics: 16 of those 20 cases were filed before Governor Ron DeSantis signed the bill on March 24, 2023, part of a wave of 280,122 civil suits rushed in ahead of the effective date, and the average one took 4.4 years to reach a verdict. 'We've seen some cases take a decade or more to reach a verdict, so there will likely be years of lag in assessing how effective Florida's legislation will be,' he said.
The report also logged a first: the first nuclear verdict involving automated driving technology, a $243 million award by a Miami jury that found Tesla partly liable for a fatal crash involving its Autopilot driver-assistance system. Marathon expects that case to set precedents as automation spreads, because liability in vehicle cases with a corporate defendant is usually shared between the company and the driver. On why awards keep growing, the researchers point to younger jurors who are more skeptical of corporations, to settlements that have become harder to reach, and to plaintiff-side advertising that now exceeds $2.5 billion a year and increasingly runs through podcasts and social media. Eight states passed significant tort reform in 2025, one of the busiest years in two decades, and Marathon still expects the trend to continue in 2026.
The Ohio Turnpike case: ten defendants for one rear-end crash
Land Line's Tyson Fisher this week walked through a case that shows how the money gets found. In August 2024, on the Ohio Turnpike, Thupten Choedon was slowing her SUV as she approached the cash and credit toll lanes when a tractor-trailer driven by Hashim Hall and operated by Best National Industries, doing business as CJJ Industries, rear-ended her. An adult passenger and a child were killed. On September 16 the National Transportation Safety Board issued its findings: the probable cause was the SUV driver's deceleration and lane change, the speed difference between the two vehicles 'did not give the truck driver sufficient opportunity to slow down or avoid the collision,' and, per Land Line's reading of the report, an automatic emergency braking system would not have responded in time either. The board's larger point was about the road. The turnpike had just installed open-road E-ZPass lanes next to traditional stop-and-pay lanes, and NTSB said the crash 'could have been avoided if the turnpike used fully electronic tolling and provided clearer information about toll payment options.' 'This crash shows the deadly safety consequences of mixing high-speed electronic tolling with low-speed manual tolling lanes,' NTSB Chairwoman Jennifer Homendy said, urging Ohio to move to fully high-speed electronic tolling, as Pennsylvania and Illinois have, and permanently close the low-speed lanes.
The lawsuit Choedon filed on July 28, through The Law Firm for Truck Safety, names Hall and CJJ Industries, as you would expect, and eight other companies. Prime AE Group, which designed the toll plaza, and Mosser Construction, which built it, are accused of negligence; the complaint says more than 250,000 motorists missed the plaza in its first two months. Mack Trucks and Volvo face product liability claims because collision mitigation, standard on the Mack Anthem, can be deleted at purchase, and it was deleted on the truck CJJ leased. M&K Quality Truck Sales, the dealership, is accused of supplying a truck that was 'unreasonably dangerous during a foreseeable collision.' And Brenntag Great Lakes, the shipper whose sulfonic acid was on the trailer, is accused of negligently hiring 'an incompetent truck company that hired an incompetent driver,' and of being the driver's employer for vicarious liability purposes because it 'had the legal right or power to direct and control' him. Land Line notes that CJJ's driver and vehicle out-of-service rates in FMCSA's records are zero after numerous inspections, and that the complaint does not explain how the shipper controlled the truck.
Two more suits sit alongside it. Hall, the truck driver, says he was at lawful speed in the correct open-road lane when the SUV braked hard, crossed into his lane and slowed to about 15 mph in a 70 mph zone; the Ohio State Highway Patrol issued him no citation, and he is suing the plaza's designer and builder, the Ohio Turnpike Commission and Choedon. A state trooper who responded, Layson, is suing the truck driver, the SUV driver, the carrier, the shipper and the commission over the acid spill, saying she was decontaminated, taken to a hospital and suffered lasting cardiac and respiratory injuries; NTSB's report says no injuries from chemical exposure were reported.
Why a driver with a clean record should read this twice
NTSB said the truck driver could not have avoided this crash. The trooper did not cite him. His carrier's out-of-service rates are zero. He is still a defendant, and so is everyone who touched the truck, the road and the load. That is the mechanism behind the $3.4 billion: the strategy is not to prove the driver was reckless but to find every party with insurance and a plausible theory. Land Line's shorthand for it is 'throwing everything at the wall to see what sticks.' The verdict, if one comes, will be split among those defendants, and the premiums to cover the next one will be split among every carrier in the country.
The bill that would take one theory off the table
The Mack and Volvo claims follow a template set in Missouri in 2024, when a jury ordered trailer maker Wabash to pay $462 million, later reduced, over a crash that killed two people even though the trailer met federal safety standards. That verdict prompted the Uniform Vehicle Safety Standards Act, introduced August 6 as S. 5336 by Senator Deb Fischer and H.R. 10050 by Representative Mike Flood, both Nebraska Republicans. It would amend 49 U.S.C. 30103 so that 'compliance with a motor vehicle safety standard prescribed under this chapter exempts a person from liability at common law for failure to exceed such standard,' making NHTSA's federal standards the ceiling for what a jury can demand of a truck or trailer. 'Americans deserve one clear set of rules instead of a patchwork of state regulations that drive up costs and create uncertainty for businesses that already follow the law,' Flood said. The American Trucking Associations, the Truckload Carriers Association, National Tank Truck Carriers and the trailer and truck manufacturers' groups back it. It would not touch negligent-hiring or vicarious-liability claims against shippers and brokers, which is where the Ohio complaint puts most of its weight.
Checklist
What an owner-operator controls
Do not delete safety options. If you spec or lease a truck, keep collision mitigation and lane departure on the build sheet; the Ohio complaint turns a deleted option into a product-liability claim against everyone in the chain.
Run a forward-facing camera and keep the footage. In the Ohio case the driver's version, no time to react, is the one NTSB confirmed. Video does that faster and cheaper than a federal investigation.
Keep your inspection record clean and your paperwork boring. Zero out-of-service rates did not keep CJJ out of the suit, but they will decide how the negligent-hiring theory plays in front of a jury.
Know your limits. The $750,000 federal minimum has not moved since 1985. Ask your agent what an umbrella costs before the renewal, not after a claim; the report's numbers are what the underwriters are looking at.
After any crash: call your insurer, say nothing to the other side's investigator, post nothing, and preserve ELD, dashcam and phone data. Deleting anything is the plaintiff's best exhibit.
Read your shipper and broker contracts for control language. The vicarious-liability theory against Brenntag rests on a 'right to direct and control' the driver; the same words in your contract cut the other way.
The business side of driving
Insurance, liability, regulation and the decisions owner-operators face, explained on Qrylo.