Cargo thieves took fewer loads this summer and made more money doing it. Verisk CargoNet's third-quarter analysis, released November 4, recorded 547 supply chain crime incidents across the United States and Canada from July through September, a 33% decline from the same quarter of 2025 and 19% below the second quarter. Estimated losses went the other way: $230.1 million, up 12% from $205.1 million a year earlier. Through September the gap is wider still. Reported incidents are down 25% year to date, from 2,755 to 2,072, while estimated losses are up 39% to $718.9 million, and the average value of a theft with a documented value has risen about 72%, from $261,115 to $448,456. 'Understanding cargo theft requires looking beyond incident counts,' said Keith Lewis, vice president of operations at Verisk CargoNet, 'and focusing on broader trends, like what is being stolen and where theft is concentrated.'
One in four thefts now starts with a fake pickup
The category that held close to steady is the one to watch. Fictitious pickups, incidents in which deception rather than force is used to obtain a shipment, accounted for 138 incidents in the quarter against 147 a year earlier, which with the overall decline lifts their share of reported activity from 18% to roughly 25%. CargoNet's earlier 2026 reporting described the methods: compromised business email accounts, internet-based phone systems and the industry load-board and verification applications carriers and brokers rely on, used to impersonate a legitimate company, obtain shipment details or redirect freight already in motion. The other route, documented in the first-quarter report, is buying a motor carrier business outright through social media, peer-to-peer marketplaces and specialized brokerage services; CargoNet has warned that a carrier selling its authority to a criminal network, knowingly or not, may face civil and criminal liability.
'We're seeing criminals combine digital deception with traditional theft tactics to identify, intercept and redirect high-value shipments,' Lewis said. 'Data center materials are among the valuable commodities attracting attention. As the value of the cargo being targeted increases, strong identity verification, shipment visibility and communication across the supply chain become even more important.' Outside estimates point the same way. A report by BSI Consulting and Munich Re Specialty, summarized by Risk & Insurance, put strategic theft, the schemes built on deception, impersonation and cyber intrusion, at about 30% of reported U.S. cargo theft incidents in 2025, with industry estimates of annual losses from organized schemes ranging from $3.5 billion to $10 billion, and found California alone accounted for nearly half of North American strategic theft incidents, with pharmaceuticals disproportionately targeted within strategic theft.
What was taken, and where
Food and beverage stayed the leading commodity with 94 incidents, down from 178; within it, nonalcoholic beverages accounted for 22, meat products 21 and alcoholic beverages 12. Household goods fell from 95 to 49 and electronics from 69 to 46, though computers and accessories remained a prominent target, 20 incidents against 24. Metals were the second most reported category at 63 incidents, barely off last year's 68, and copper was 34 of them. Personal care and beauty declined from 44 to 39 overall, but cosmetics thefts rose from nine to 14. CargoNet's reading is that product-level patterns can persist or grow while category totals fall, and that these categories are particularly notable theft targets ahead of the holidays.
Geographically, California accounted for about a third of all reported incidents with 182, down from 261. New Jersey fell from 66 to 46, Illinois from 52 to 40 and Texas from 105 to 43. The four states together were 57% of the quarter. At county level the concentrations were Los Angeles, San Bernardino and Riverside in California, Harris County in Texas and Cook County in Illinois. The counts run through October 23 by report date, and CargoNet notes that prior-period figures move as late reports arrive.
South of the border: the hit moves to the parking lot
Mexico's third quarter showed a different kind of shift. Overhaul's Q3 2026 cargo theft analysis, reported by FreightWaves, found thefts involving parked commercial vehicles were 42.2% of reported incidents, up nine percentage points from a year earlier, while thefts of trucks intercepted in motion fell 8.6 points to 55.4%, narrowing the gap between the two to about 13 points. Parked-vehicle thefts cluster at high-risk roadside locations, including informal truck stops and areas associated with illicit fuel sales. 'Now, in Mexico, you can't move loads without a plan,' said Luis Enrique Villatoro, president of ANERPV, the national association of vehicle tracking and protection companies, who discussed the findings during an Overhaul webinar. 'There are some [parking lots] that are more insecure than others,' said Overhaul sales director Ricardo Malacara. 'And the status of safe havens is changing.'
The geography is the set of industrial corridors connecting central Mexico to the U.S. border. Central Mexico and the Bajío together accounted for 76% of incidents, 48% and 28% respectively. The State of Mexico remained the largest hotspot at 22.5%, followed by Puebla at 15% and Guanajuato at 9.6%, a combined 47%. The northeast's share doubled from 6% to 12% and the southeast's rose from 6% to about 11.5%. Villatoro singled out San Luis Potosí, on the corridors linking Bajío plants to the northeast, and described groups using multiple vehicles, including tractor-trailers, to block highways between Lagos de Moreno and San Luis Potosí, and activity shifting from the Querétaro-Celaya corridor toward San Luis de la Paz when enforcement moved in. 'What is happening at this moment is that they are mutating,' he said. Timing moved too: 61% of thefts occurred between 6 p.m. and 6 a.m., and the midnight-to-6 a.m. window grew from 22% to 31%; weekdays were still 82% of incidents but Saturday's share rose from 7% to 11%.
Food and beverage was 32.6% of Mexican incidents, up 7.3 points. Electronics were 6.1%, but concentrated: 94% of electronics thefts occurred in central Mexico, the Bajío and the northeast, and five highways carried 73% of them, led by the Mexico City-Saltillo corridor on Federal Highway 57D at 23%, Querétaro-Zacatecas on 45D at 18% and Chamapa-Guadalajara at 16%. Overhaul also found 85% of electronics thefts were trucks intercepted in transit, and, unlike the general pattern, in daylight: 42% between noon and 6 p.m. and another 31% between 6 a.m. and noon.
Why fewer incidents can cost more
A fictitious pickup obtains the shipment through deception rather than force: the thief, posing as the carrier, is handed the load at the dock. As that method's share of reported incidents grows from 18% to 25%, and as BSI and Munich Re describe deliberate selection of high-value cargo, the average loss per incident can rise even while the incident count falls; that link is our reading, not CargoNet's stated conclusion. Separately, CargoNet notes it has historically observed increased theft activity in the fourth quarter and into the new year, and says activity could escalate as criminals exploit extended facility closures and reduced staffing over the holidays, with particular attention to fictitious pickups and high-value commodities.
Before the holiday freeze
Verify identity beyond the tender. Confirm the carrier through a phone number and email on record, not the ones in the load confirmation; a compromised mailbox or VoIP line is the entry point CargoNet describes.
Treat a recently sold or reactivated authority as a new carrier. CargoNet documents outright purchases of carrier businesses; recent changes in ownership, address, contacts or insurance can indicate one.
Match the driver to the dispatch at the dock. Name, license, truck and trailer numbers against what the carrier sent, and a callback to the carrier if any of it differs.
Keep visibility on in transit. Shipment visibility is one of the controls CargoNet's Lewis calls more important as targeted cargo values rise.
Do not stage high-value loads over a holiday weekend. Closed facilities and skeleton staffing are the window CargoNet flags for the fourth quarter.
In Mexico, plan the stops before departure. Pre-approved secure parking and no informal roadside stops; for electronics, note that Overhaul's data put 85% of thefts in transit, 73% on five highways led by the 57D, the 45D and Chamapa-Guadalajara, and most of them in daylight.
The incident count is the number that gets quoted and the one that is improving. The dollar figure is the one the insurer, the shipper and the carrier actually pay, and it is up 39% on the year with a quarter to go that CargoNet notes has historically seen more activity. On the numbers, the trade is stealing less often and taking more per hit, and the method that held its ground is the one that starts with a stolen identity rather than a bolt cutter.
Know who you are handing the load to.
Qrylo follows cargo theft, freight fraud and carrier vetting in plain language for brokers, shippers and the carriers who move the freight, alongside equipment listings and carrier tools.