For a year and a half the federal push on English-language proficiency has been measured in press releases. This week it came with a ratio. The third wave of Operation Highway Shield, a 48-hour operation run October 27 through 29 at Arkansas weigh stations by the Arkansas Highway Police together with FMCSA, the Drug Enforcement Administration, Homeland Security Investigations and ICE, produced 1,724 inspections and placed 393 drivers and vehicles out of service, the Arkansas Department of Transportation reported. Of those, 183 were English-language proficiency violations. That is nearly half of everything the operation parked, and it is the number Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy highlighted on November 4: 'This latest wave of Operation Highway Shield has pulled over 300 dangerous drivers off the road including 183 foreign drivers that couldn't read road signs.'
What Arkansas produced, and how the share has moved
The rest of the Arkansas tally, per the state DOT and Land Line: more than 330 drivers identified as unqualified or unauthorized, more than 1,000 motor carrier safety violations, 369 traffic citations or warnings, 44 criminal arrests, 74 immigration violations referred for federal enforcement and one stolen trailer recovered. Arkansas Highway Police Chief Jeff Holmes said the operation 'simply shines a spotlight on what our officers do every single day.' FMCSA Administrator Derek Barrs, who was in the state for the event, called it 'more boots on the ground, identifying unsafe drivers and vehicles, and taking decisive action to keep dangerous operators off our roadways.'
Set the three announced waves side by side and the language share is the thing that changed. Wave one, Florida, March: 176 drivers out of service, 54 for language deficiencies, roughly three in ten. Wave two, July 28 to 30 per FreightWaves, in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa and Ohio: 766 drivers and vehicles out of service, 36 English-proficiency violations, roughly one in twenty, with 51 immigration detentions and about $1 million in stolen cargo recovered, per FreightWaves. Wave three, Arkansas: 183 of 393. The counts mix drivers with vehicles and the operations were not run identically, so the ratios are a rough guide, not a trend line. But Arkansas was run at select weigh stations with what the state called 'enhanced operations,' and about one inspection in ten there, 183 of 1,724, ended in an English-proficiency out-of-service order.
The smaller operations show the same order at a smaller scale. In Stephens City, Virginia, FMCSA's Virginia Division, the Virginia State Police and the state DMV ran 86 Level I inspections, found 100 violations and placed 11 vehicles and two drivers out of service, one of them for English proficiency, FreightWaves reported. Inside Operation Guardian, the 15-state immigration dragnet of October 26 to 28 whose results we reported this week, Indiana State Police inspected just over 500 commercial vehicles, ordered 85 vehicles and 51 drivers out of service, eight of the drivers for English proficiency, and made 28 criminal arrests, per Transport Topics. In September, Operation Saturday Night Fever, run by FMCSA, DHS and state agencies, placed 78 drivers and 25 vehicles out of service, Land Line noted.
26,000 in August, 33,000 in November
Alongside the Arkansas results, DOT published its running totals as of November 4: 33,000 commercial drivers placed out of service nationwide for failing English-language proficiency since President Trump's April 2025 executive order, 31,000 commercial driver's licenses revoked that the department describes as improperly issued to unvetted foreign drivers, and nearly 10,000 commercial driving schools shut down. In August the agency had put the first figure at 26,000, which Land Line reads as an increase of 7,000 over roughly three months. DOT also restated that in August FMCSA removed 110 driver training schools associated with more than 5,000 drivers who failed English-proficiency tests and put another 160 schools on notice. FreightWaves added the caveat that matters for anyone quoting these numbers: the department did not provide a detailed accounting of how the nationwide totals were calculated.
'Gone are the days of dangerous–and many times illegal and foreign–drivers putting American lives at risk on our roads,' Duffy said in the statement. 'We are not slowing down when it comes to keeping Americans safe on our roads.' Barrs: 'Every person on the road deserves to get home safely. When criminal activity and unsafe vehicles creep onto our highways, it puts everyone at risk.'
The rule that would make it permanent: FMCSA-2026-0826
The out-of-service order for English proficiency is, at this moment, a product of two policy choices that could in theory be reversed. The regulation itself, 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2), has required since long before 2025 that a driver be able to read and speak English well enough to converse with the public, understand traffic signs and signals, respond to officials and make entries on records. Whether a violation parks the truck has been decided by the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance's out-of-service criteria. Land Line's Jami Jones traced the history in August: CVSA added English proficiency to the criteria in April 2005 and dropped it about a decade later. OOIDA's Doug Morris told the association's board that in 2014 the regulation produced 101,280 violations and only 4,036 out-of-service orders. CVSA went so far as to petition FMCSA to delete the regulation entirely; the agency declined, and CVSA members voted to stop issuing the order anyway. The April 2025 executive order and an OOIDA petition brought it back, and CVSA then asked FMCSA to put the order in the federal regulations themselves.
FMCSA's answer was the proposed rule published August 10, Federal Register document 2026-16288, RIN 2126-AC99, which would codify the English-language proficiency requirement as an out-of-service violation in the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, 'aligning' them with the current CVSA criteria. A precedent is 392.5, the alcohol prohibition, which carries a federally mandated 24-hour out-of-service order no roadside association can vote away. The proposal exempts drivers who operate only inside the U.S.-Mexico border commercial zone unless there is evidence they operate or plan to operate beyond it, and, as Land Line noted, does not say how long the order lasts. Comments closed October 9; as of November 6 regulations.gov lists 2,203 public submissions on the docket. OOIDA filed in support in early October, calling English proficiency 'a life-and-death safety standard': 'Truckers drive 80,000-pound vehicles through all kinds of terrain – steep mountain passes, narrow turns and busy city streets. The only thing separating safe trips from deadly ones can be a simple road sign,' the association wrote over President Todd Spencer's signature. FMCSA is reviewing the comments before deciding how to proceed, Land Line reports; no decision has been announced.
What changes if the rule is finalized, and what does not
Nothing changes at the roadside tomorrow: the order is already in CVSA's criteria and inspectors are already issuing it, 33,000 times by DOT's count. What changes is who can turn it off. Today a CVSA membership vote could remove the out-of-service consequence, as it did around 2015, and a future administration could withdraw the May 2025 enforcement guidance. A regulation can only be undone by another rulemaking, with notice, comment and a record that survives in court. That is the point of the proposal, and the reason supporters like OOIDA filed.
The wider machinery
English proficiency is one gear in a larger set. FMCSA's final rule on non-domiciled CDLs, which took effect in March and which the agency expects to make roughly 200,000 current holders ineligible, was argued before the D.C. Circuit on September 15 and awaits a ruling. Ohio has announced it is ending its non-domiciled CDL program outright. Operation Guardian put 15 states and ICE on the same 72 hours to defeat social-media warnings that told drivers to route around Oklahoma. And the operations are arriving in quick succession: Florida in March, the Midwest in July, Operation Guardian, which included Arkansas, and Arkansas's own Highway Shield wave in the same week of October, Virginia disclosed in November. Barrs said the agency will 'continue working shoulder to shoulder with our partners'; Duffy's phrasing was 'not slowing down.'
For carriers and drivers, the practical side
The roadside test is a conversation. Under FMCSA's May 2025 enforcement guidance, inspectors assess whether the driver can converse in English and understand highway signs; a driver who cannot is placed out of service, and in practice the load waits for a qualified driver.
The violation follows the carrier. An English-proficiency out-of-service order is a driver qualification violation that appears on the inspection report and in the carrier's safety data.
Document qualification before dispatch. The regulation's standard, reading and speaking English sufficiently to converse with the public, understand signs and respond to officials, is the carrier's to verify at hiring under 391.11, not the inspector's to discover.
Weigh stations are the venue. Arkansas ran its operation at select scale sites with 'enhanced operations'; Indiana worked bypass routes to catch trucks avoiding the interstates. Routing around one state does not help when fifteen are working the same hours.
Border zone is the exception, narrowly. The proposed rule would not park a driver operating solely within the U.S.-Mexico commercial zone, but evidence of operation beyond it removes the exception.
Watch the docket. A final rule on FMCSA-2026-0826 would fix the order in regulation; until then, the order rests on CVSA's criteria and the 2025 guidance.
A number that grows by 7,000 in roughly three months is not an enforcement blitz; it is a steady state, with the caveat that DOT's cumulative totals come without a published method. The Arkansas ratio, nearly one out-of-service order in two tied to language, is the highest share of the three announced waves. The proposed rule would make the order a regulation rather than a policy, which is to say harder for any future administration or roadside association to undo. Whatever a carrier thinks of the policy, the operational fact is settled: a driver who cannot hold a roadside conversation in English can be parked at any inspection in the country, and the states are now coordinating when they look.
Enforcement is a schedule now. Qrylo keeps the calendar.
Qrylo follows FMCSA rulemakings, enforcement operations and court dates in plain language for the people who hold the CDL and the DOT number, alongside equipment listings and carrier tools.